Uncovering Wilson’s Fountain
By Tom Joseph
A Constitutional Framers’s Overlooked Law Lecture
Founding father James Wilson deserved his own chapter in our history books. Fatefully, Americans need a search engine to learn the first thing about him. In my case, a democratic initiative sought a brand name. One befitting a revolutionary concept.
An analysis of our voting process led to discovering a critical flaw and an easy way to fix it. A solution inadvertently built on a constitutional principle: elections must be literally free and equal.
The internet returned a law review article published in January 2023 crediting James Wilson with adding the words "and equal" to language that for a century was simply a free election clause. It quoted a passage where Wilson describes free and equal elections as "the original fountain" from which all government flows and warns of catastrophe if the font is poisoned.
The article placed the excerpt immediately after Wilson's recognition for delivering America's first law lecture. The timing of the event, coupled with Pennsylvania's 1790 Constitutional Convention, made the quote read as if it were a keynote of this famous speech. I figured legal scholars must have known this nuanced wording.
Clarification surfaced with the recent release of Jesse Wegman's book, The Lost Founder, which contains numerous contributions from Professor William Ewald — a James Wilson scholar at the University of Pennsylvania Law School. I previously connected with Professor Ewald regarding Wilson and emailed a congratulatory note. The exchange led to a meeting and an opportunity to get his take on the fountain lecture. What I got was a puzzled look.
Wilson drafted and delivered fifty-eight law lectures at Franklin’s College of Philadelphia, now Penn. Only one captured considerable attention due to its historic nature and an audience including President George Washington, his cabinet, and the first Congress. The remaining fifty-seven, covering a vast array of topics, were heard by a small class of law students. The lesson of Wilson’s fountain ended up buried under his own prolific writing.
The story of James Wilson is compelling. In the end, he died hiding in financial ruin while presiding on the Supreme Court. Recognized in revolutionary times for his brilliance, his bankruptcy diminished his reputation so thoroughly that his published works went unheralded. His substantial contributions to the writing and ratification of The United States Constitution are commonly unattributed. Tragically, it was Wilson himself who erased his rightful place in American history.
Legal minds may interpret the fountain metaphor as a decoration. A flourish appended to a dry constitutional principle. But from an engineer's perspective, his analogy offers three symbolic aspects of a foretold system failure, each having its own merits.
First, it locates the source of the infirmity. In this case, it is not one input among many. By calling free and equal elections the "original fountain," Wilson is making a structural claim: government does not have co-equal foundations that might undo the failing of another. It has one. Get it wrong, and no branch, institution, or law, will be able to compensate.
Second, it identifies the form of harm. Wilson's warning isn't that elections might become merely flawed or imperfect. He says poison will travel from the point of origin. A spoiled fountain doesn't stay contained; it penetrates everything that draws from it, indiscriminately and progressively. It is a specific theory of institutional failure: not that bad outcomes accumulate from small errors scattered across the government, but they originate upstream and spread ruinously.
Third, the metaphor suggests its own remedy. A toxic spring isn’t fixed by treating the water after it has been released. Cleansing the source is the only way to solve it. Once the well is pure, everything fed by it recovers on its own. Wilson isn't just diagnosing a vulnerability; he tells us where the intervention must occur.
Taken together, these three functions make the fountain more than an evocative image. It's a compact theory of where legitimacy comes from, how it degrades, and where repair has to be targeted. There is a lot of conceptual weight resting on a passage that, as it turns out, almost nobody studying Wilson had uncovered.
The fountain analogy is a diagnostic: not whether an electoral outcome satisfies the people, but whether the mechanism producing it is in fact equal, not just free. An open primary here, a ranked choice system there, even a Citizens United overturned — none of it matters if the water still comes from the same polluted place. The real test is simple, if uncomfortable: are we treating the problem, or just attempting to purify what’s already tainted?
That assessment doesn't require agreeing with me, or with Wilson, of what a "free and equal" system looks like. It's about starting with the source, rather than the symptom, which is how political arguments are typically approached.
Wilson was telling us something self-evident. That finding our true voice results from an absolutely fair method of selection. Ignore that fact at our own peril.
I didn't conclude that by reading Wilson. He got there first, with a lecture I'd never known about if a query hadn't displayed an obscure citation on my screen. But a solution doesn't belong to him any more than it belongs to me. Because it won't happen until we all take our broken politics seriously enough to address the root cause.